.jpg)
When a good contractor hands in their notice, the assumption is usually that someone offered them a better rate. Our 2026 snapshot survey of 482 contractors and hiring managers suggests that assumption is increasingly out of date. Contractors are now almost evenly split on what matters most: 51% say flexibility is more important than pay, against 49% who put pay first. For a growing share of your workforce, where and how they work now weighs as heavily as what they're paid to do it.
The retention cost is already real
This isn't a soft preference employers can note and move on from. More than a quarter of hiring managers (28%) have already lost candidates or existing contractors specifically because they couldn't offer the flexibility being asked for. That's talent walking out of the door, or never walking in, over something that often has nothing to do with budget.
In a market where around 88% of employers already find specialist contractors hard to source, losing good people over working arrangements is an expensive way to run a team.
What contractors actually mean by "flexibility"
Flexibility isn't one thing. For 59% of contractors, flexible working location is a main consideration when choosing a role, and 44% cite flexible hours. Preferred working models tell the same story: 59% want hybrid arrangements and 25% want to be fully remote, leaving just 15% who are happy to be predominantly on site or in an office.
Culture sits close behind. In some sectors, an unsuitable team culture is the single most common reason contractors give for leaving a role early, a reminder that "flexibility" is often shorthand for a broader question about whether an organisation is a good place to work.
It's "and," not "or"
None of this means pay stops mattering. Pay is still cited by 79% of contractors as a main consideration, and half still rank it first. The shift is that flexibility has drawn level with pay rather than replacing it. Employers who treat the two as a straight trade-off, assuming a strong rate will always win, are the ones most likely to be caught out when a contractor leaves.
The advantage is that flexibility is often cheaper to offer than a pay rise, and much harder for a competitor to simply outbid.
James Fernandes, Co-Founder and Managing Director at Carrington West, sees this as an opportunity as much as a challenge: "Flexibility has quietly become one of the most powerful retention tools employers have , and one of the cheapest. The organisations winning the best contractors aren't always the ones paying the most; they're the ones offering trust, hybrid options and a culture people want to stay in. The encouraging thing is that it's fixable. Employers who get deliberate about where and how work happens can hold on to their best people without simply chasing the market on rate."
Turning flexibility into a retention advantage
The practical step is to stop treating flexibility as a blanket yes or no. Define which roles and tasks genuinely need on-site presence, offer flexibility everywhere it doesn't compromise delivery, and be explicit with contractors about where the lines are. Done well, that clarity becomes a selling point and one of the most cost-effective retention tools you have.
Your best contractors may not be motivated purely by money. The good news is that keeping them may not cost as much as you think.
Our 2026 snapshot survey explores how flexibility is reshaping contractor retention, alongside four other culture shifts in the UK contract workforce. Download the report below to see the full findings.